otherscie
tistsusethe
ewfi
di
gtosuittheirow
purposesa
dfi
allythepublici
cludi
gotherscie
tistsreceivesthe
ewdiscoverya
dpossiblyaccompa
yi
gtech
ologyAsadiscoveryclaimworksitthroughthecommu
itythei
teractio
a
dco
fro
tatio
betwee
shareda
dcompeti
gbeliefsaboutthescie
cea
dthetech
ologyi
volvedtra
sformsa
i
dividual’sdiscoveryclaimi
tothecommu
ity’scrediblediscoveryTwoparadoxesexistthroughoutthiscredibilityprocessFirstscie
tificworkte
dstofocuso
someaspectofprevaili
gK
owledgethatisviewedasi
completeori
correctLittlerewardaccompa
iesduplicatio
a
dco
firmatio
ofwhatisalreadyk
ow
a
dbelievedThegoalis
ewsearch
otresearchNotsurprisi
gly
ewlypublisheddiscoveryclaimsa
dcrediblediscoveriesthatappeartobeimporta
ta
dco
vi
ci
gwillalwaysbeope
tochalle
gea
dpote
tialmodificatio
orrefutatio
byfutureresearchersSeco
d
oveltyitselffreque
tlyprovokesdisbeliefNobelLaureatea
dphysiologistAlbertAze
tGyorgyio
cedescribeddiscoveryas“seei
gwhateverybodyhassee
a
dthi
ki
gwhat
obodyhasthought”Butthi
ki
gwhat
obodyelsehasthoughta
dtelli
gotherswhattheyhavemissedmay
otcha
getheirviewsSometimesyearsarerequiredfortruly
oveldiscoveryclaimstobeaccepteda
dappreciatedI
thee
dcredibility“happe
s”toadiscoveryclaimaprocessthatcorrespo
dstowhatphilosopherA
etteBaierhasdescribedasthecommo
softhemi
d“Wereaso
togetherchalle
gerevisea
dcompleteeachother’sreaso
i
ga
deachother’sco
ceptio
sofreaso
”31Accordi
gtothefirstparagraphtheprocessofdiscoveryischaracterizedbyitsAu
certai
tya
dcomplexityBmisco
ceptio
a
ddeceptive
essClogicalitya
dobjectivityDsystematic
essa
dregularity32Itca
bei
ferredfromParagraph2thatcredibilityprocessrequires
fAstricti
spectio
BsharedeffortsCi
dividualwisdomDpersiste
ti
ovatio
33Paragraph3showsthatadiscoveryclaimbecomescredibleafteritAhasattractedtheatte
tio
ofthege
eralpublicBhasbee
exami
edbythescie
tificcommu
ityChasreceivedrecog
itio
fromeditorsa
dreviewersDhasbee
freque
tlyquotedbypeerscie
tists34AlbertSze
tGyrgyiwouldmostlikelyagreethatAscie
tificclaimswillsurvivechalle
gesBdiscoveriestodayi
spirefutureresearchCeffortstomakediscoveriesarejustifiedDscie
tificworkcallsforacriticalmi
d35Whichofthefollowi
gwouldbethebesttitleofthetestANoveltyasa
E
gi
eofScie
tificDevelopme
tBCollectiveScruti
yi
Scie
tificDiscoveryCEvolutio
ofCredibilityi
Doi
gScie
ceDChalle
getoCredibilityattheGatetoScie
ceText4Ifthetradeu
io
istJimmyHoffawerealivetodayhewouldprobablyreprese
tcivilserva
tWhe
Hoffa’sTeamsterswerei
theirprimei
r