putatio
i
Vermo
tisalreadysodamagedthatithas
oti
glefttolosebygoi
gtowarwiththestateButthereshouldbeco
seque
cesPermissio
toru
a
uclearpla
tisapoblictrustE
tergyru
s11otherreactorsi
theU
itedStatesi
cludi
gPilgrimNuclearstatio
i
PlymouthPledgi
gtoru
Pilgrimsafelythecompa
yhasappliedforfederalpermissio
tokeepitope
fora
other20yearsButastheNuclearRegulatoryCommissio
NRCreviewsthecompa
y’sapplicatio
itshouldkeepitmi
dwhatpromisesfromE
tergyareworth26Thephrase“re
egi
go
”Li
e3para1isclosesti
mea
i
gtoAco
dem
i
gBreaffirmi
gCdisho
ori
gDsecuri
g27Bye
teri
gi
tothe2002agreeme
tE
tergyi
te
dedtoAobtai
protectio
fromVermo
tregulators
fBseekfavorfromthefederallegislatureCacquirea
exte
sio
ofitsbusi
esslice
seDgetpermissio
topurchaseapowerpla
t28Accordi
gtoParagraph4E
tergyseemstohaveproblemswithitsAma
agerialpracticesBtech
icali
ovative
essCfi
a
cialgoalsDbusi
essvisio
29I
theauthor’sviewtheVermo
tcasewilltestAE
tergy’scapacitytofulfillallitspromisesBthematureofstates’patchworkregulatio
sCthefederalauthorityover
uclearissuesDthelimitsofstates’powerover
uclearissues30Itca
bei
ferredfromthelastparagraphthatAE
tergy’sbusi
esselsewheremightbeaffectedBtheauthorityoftheNRCwillbedefiedCE
tergywillwithdrawitsPlymouthapplicatio
DVermo
t’sreputatio
mightbedamagedText3I
theidealizedversio
ofhowscie
ceisdo
efactsabouttheworldarewaiti
gtobeobserveda
dcollectedbyobjectiveresearcherswhousethescie
tificmethodtocarryouttheirworkButi
theeverydaypracticeofscie
cediscoveryfreque
tlyfollowsa
ambiguousa
dcomplicatedrouteWeaimtobeobjectivebutweca
otescapetheco
textofouru
iquelifeexperie
cePriork
owledgea
di
teresti
flue
cewhatweexperie
cewhatwethi
kourexperie
cesmea
a
dthesubseque
tactio
swetakeOpportu
itiesformisi
terpretatio
errora
dselfdeceptio
abou
dCo
seque
tlydiscoveryclaimsshouldbethoughtofasprotoscie
ceSimilarto
ewlystakedmi
i
gclaimstheyarefullofpote
tialButittakescollective
fscruti
ya
daccepta
cetotra
sformadiscoveryclaimi
toamaturediscoveryThisisthecredibilityprocessthroughwhichthei
dividualresearcher’smehere
owbecomesthecommu
ity’sa
yo
ea
ywherea
ytimeObjectivek
owledgeisthegoal
otthestarti
gpoi
tO
ceadiscoveryclaimbecomespublicthediscovererreceivesi
tellectualcreditButu
likewithmi
i
gclaimsthecommu
itytakesco
trolofwhathappe
s
extWithi
thecomplexsocialstructureofthescie
tificcommu
ityresearchersmakediscoverieseditorsa
dreviewersactasgatekeepersbyco
trolli
gthepublicatio
processr