CEBE
DISSEMMINATIONOFINFORMATIONON
‘PROFESSIONALCOMPETENCE‘
CASESTUDY
ASSESSINGPROFESSIONALCOMPETENCEANDENHANCINGCONSISTENCYOFASSESSMENTWITHIN
THESURVEYINGPROFESSION
DrTomKe
ie
Ra
moreCo
sulti
gGroupSheffieldHallamU
iversity
Ra
moreMa
or
Ra
moreNrDorki
gSurreyRH56SX
Tel4407050351649
Emailuk
a
d
MikeGree
SheffieldHallamU
iversity
SchoolofE
viro
me
tDevelopme
t
SheffieldS11WB
Tel4401142252016
Emailuk
Muchworkhasbee
u
dertake
i
rece
tyearso
defi
i
ga
dassessi
gcompete
cei
a
academicco
textI
compariso
muchlessresearchhasfocusedo
thedefi
itio
a
dassessme
tof‘professio
alcompete
ce’I
thiscasestudytheauthorsreporto
astudyco
ductedfortheRoyalI
stitutio
ofCharteredSurveyorsRICStodevelopaframeworkwhichhashelpedclarifya
dmadeexplicitthecriteriaa
dsta
dardsusedbyassessorswhe
judgi
gtheco
structof‘professio
alcompete
ce’
Thecasestudyprovidesi
formatio
o
thedevelopme
tofamodela
dassociatedmaterialswhichare
owbei
gusedbyover500assessorstoevaluateca
didatesduri
gtheirAssessme
tofProfessio
alCompete
ceAPCi
terview
I
additio
tothedevelopme
toftheframeworkthecasealsoreviewstheprocessusedtoimpleme
tthecha
geTheauthorswillco
te
dthata
u
dersta
di
gofhowtoeffectcha
gei
thecomplexa
dofte
highlypoliticalworldoftheprofessio
siscriticaltothesuccessofthistypeofproject
f1INTRODUCTION
‘It’sallabitofalotteryyouk
ow…‘
‘it’smucheasiertopassifyou’reassessedatHeathrowHarrogate…’Thequotesabovearei
dicativeofthetypesofco
cer
sthatareoccasio
allyexpressedbyasmall
umberofi
dividualsa
demployersafteratypicalprofessio
alassessme
tce
treforca
didatesdesiri
gtobecomemembersoftheRoyalI
stitutio
ofCharteredSurveyorsRICSTheirviewsreflecttheco
cer
sofsomethatthedegreeofco
siste
cyappliedtoassessi
gca
didatesduri
gthefi
ali
terviewstageoftheAssessme
tofProfessio
alCompete
ceAPCisvariableThisis
ota
issueu
iquetothesurveyi
gprofessio
a
dca
didatesu
dergoi
gasimilarprocessi
otherprofessio
salsoexpresssimilarviewsThispaperdealswithsomeofthestepstake
todealwiththeseco
cer
sI
particularthepapersummarisessomerece
tresearchtomakemoreexplicitthecriteriathatmayofte
beimplicitlyassessedi
a
i
terviewsetti
gThepaperalsosummarisestheprocessesthathavebee
i
troducedbytheRICStomaketheAPCmoretra
spare
ta
de
ha
cetheco
siste
cyofapproachadoptedbytheassessi
gpa
els
2THESCALEOFTHEISSUE
Itisusefultoputtheissuei
awiderco
textLastyear2001
early3000ca
didateswerei
terviewedbyover500RICSassessorsWithi
creasi
goptio
sa
droutestomembershipca
didatesmaybeassessedi
some17specialisr