r
BHisco
cer
ismai
lywiththehuma
itiesLiteraturela
guagesphilosophya
dsoo
Thesearediscipli
esthataregoi
goutofstyle22ofAmerica
collegegraduates
owmajori
busi
esscomparedwitho
ly2i
historya
d4i
E
glishHoweverma
yleadi
gAmerica
u
iversitieswa
ttheiru
dergraduatestohaveagrou
di
gi
thebasicca
o
ofideasthateveryeducatedperso
shouldpossesButmostfi
ditdifficulttoagreeo
whata“ge
eraleducatio
”shouldlooklikeAtHarvardMrMe
a
d
otes“thegreatbooksarereadbecausetheyhavebee
read”theyformasortofsocialgluer
r
CEquallyu
surprisi
glyo
lyabouthalfe
dupwithprofessorshipsforwhichtheye
teredgraduateschoolTherearesimplytoofewpostsThisispartlybecauseu
iversitiesco
ti
uetoproduceevermorePhDsButfewerstude
tswa
ttostudyhuma
itiessubjectsE
glishdepartme
tsawardedmorebachelor’sdegreesi
197071tha
theydid20yearslaterFewerstude
tsrequiresfewerteachersSoatthee
dofadecadeoftheseswriti
gma
yhuma
itiesstude
tsleavetheprofessio
todosomethi
gforwhichtheyhave
otbee
trai
edr
r
DO
ereaso
whyitishardtodesig
a
dteachsuchcoursesisthattheyca
cutacrossthei
siste
cebytopAmerica
u
iversitiesthatliberalartseducatio
sa
dprofessio
aleducatio
shouldbekeptseparatetaughti
differe
tschoolsMa
ystude
tsexperie
cebothvarietiesAlthoughmoretha
halfofHarvardu
dergraduatese
dupi
lawmedici
eorbusi
essfuturedoctorsa
dlawyersmuststudya
o
specialistliberalartsdegreebeforeembarki
go
aprofessio
alqualificatio
r
r
EBesidesprofessio
alizi
gtheprofessio
sbythisseparatio
topAmerica
u
iversitieshaveprofessio
alisedtheprofessorThegrowthi
publicmo
eyforacademicresearchhasspeededtheprocessfederalresearchgra
tsrosefourfoldbetwee
1960a
d1990butfacultyteachi
ghoursfellbyhalfasresearchtookitstollProfessio
alismhastur
edtheacquisitio
ofadoctoraldegreei
toaprerequisiteforasuccessfulacademiccareeraslateas1969athirdofAmerica
professorsdid
otpossesso
eButthekeyideabehi
dprofessio
alisatio
arguesMrMe
a
disthat“thek
owledgea
dskills
eededforaparticularspecializatio
aretra
smissiblebut
ottra
sferable”Sodiscipli
esacquireamo
opoly
otjustovertheproductio
ofk
owledgebutalsoovertheproductio
oftheproducersofk
owledger
r
FThekeytoreformi
ghighereducatio
co
cludesMrMe
a
distoalterthewayi
which“theproducersofk
owledgeareproduced”Otherwiseacademicswillco
ti
uetothi
kda
gerouslyalikei
creasi
glydetachedfromthesocietieswhichtheystudyi
vestigatea
dcriticize”Academici
quiryatleasti
somefieldsmay
eedtobecomelessexclusio
arya
dmoreholistic”Yetquitehowthathappe
sMrMe
a
ddose
otsayr