isio
swereflawed“Eachyearthephysicalprese
cerulebecomesfurtherremovedfromeco
omicreality
fa
dresultsi
sig
ifica
treve
uelossestotheStates”hewrotei
a
opi
io
joi
edbyfourotherjusticesKe
edywrotethattherule“limitedstates’abilitytoseeklo
gtermprosperitya
dhaspreve
tedmarketparticipa
tsfromcompeti
go
a
eve
playi
gfield”
Theruli
gisavictoryforbigchai
swithaprese
cei
ma
ystatessi
cetheyusuallycollectsalestaxo
o
li
epurchasesalreadyNowrivalswillbechargi
gsalestaxwheretheyhad
’tbeforeBigchai
shavebee
collecti
gsalestax
atio
widebecausetheytypicallyhavephysicalstoresi
whateverstateapurchaseisbei
gshippedtoAmazo
comwithits
etworkofwarehousesalsocollectssalestaxi
everystatethatchargesitthoughthirdpartysellerswhousethesitedo
’thaveto
U
til
owma
ysellersthathaveaphysicalprese
cei
o
lyasi
glestateorafewstateshavebee
abletoavoidchargi
gsalestaxeswhe
theyshiptoaddressesoutsidethosestatesSellersthatuseeBaya
dEtsywhichprovideplatformsforsmallersellersalsohave
’tbee
collecti
gsalestax
atio
wideU
dertheruli
gThursdaystatesca
passlawsrequiri
goutofstatesellerstocollectthestate’ssalestaxfromcustomersa
dse
dittothestate
Retailtradegroupspraisedtheruli
gsayi
gitlevelstheplayi
gfieldforlocala
do
li
ebusi
essesTheloserssaidretaila
alystNeilSau
dersareo
li
eo
lyretailersespeciallysmallero
esThoseretailersmayfaceheadachescomplyi
gwithvariousstatesalestaxlawsThe
SmallBusi
essE
trepre
eurshipCou
ciladvocacygroupsaidi
aastateme
t“Smallbusi
essesa
di
ter
ete
trepre
eursare
otwellservedatallbythisdecisio
”
36TheSupremeCourtdecisio
ThursdaywillADettebusi
ess’relutio
swithstatesBputmosto
li
ebusi
essi
adilemmaCmakemoreo
li
eshopperspaysalestaxDforcessomestatestocutsalestax
f37Itca
belear
edfromparagraphs2a
d3thattheoverruleddecisio
sAhaveledtothedomi
a
ceofecommerceBhavecostco
sumersalotovertheyearsCwerewidelycriticizedbyo
li
epurchasesDwereco
sideredupfavorablebystates38Accordi
gtoJusticeA
tho
yKe
edythephysicalprese
cerulehasAhi
deredeco
omicdevelopme
tBbroughtprosperitytothecou
tryCharmedfairmarketcompetitio
Dboostedgrowthi
statesreve
ue39WhoaremostlikelytowelcometheSupremeCourtruli
gAI
ter
ete
trepre
eursBBigchairow
ersCThirdpartysellersDSmallretailers40I
deali
gwiththeSupremeCourtdecisio
ThursdaytheauthorAgivesafactualaccou
tofita
ddiscussesitsco
seque
cesBdescribesthelo
ga
dcomplicatedprocessofitsmaki
gCprese
tsitsmai
poi
tswithco
flicti
gviewso
themDcitiessomesacesrelatedtoita
da
alyzestheirimplicatio
sPartBDirectio
sr