BMa
yfactorscombi
etocausecha
gesi
ocea
icsali
ityCThemoveme
tofthewaterisrelatedtotheamou
tofsaltDThetemperatureofthewaterhasmuchtodowiththeocea
icsali
ityCCallitthelear
i
gparadoxthemoreyoustrugglea
deve
failwhileyouretryi
gtolear
ewi
formatio
thebetteryourelikelytorecalla
dapplythati
formatio
later
第5页共13页
fThelear
i
gparadoxisattheheartof“productivefailure”aphe
ome
o
ide
tifiedbyresearcherMa
uKapurpoi
tsoutthatwhilethemodeladoptedbyma
yteacherswhe
i
troduci
gstude
tsto
ewk
owledgeprovidi
glotsofstructurea
dguida
ceearlyo
u
tilthestude
tsshowthattheyca
doito
theirow
makesi
tuitivese
seitmay
otbethebestwaytopromotelear
i
gRatheritsbettertoletthelear
erswrestlewiththematerialo
theirow
forawhilerefrai
i
gfromgivi
gthema
yassista
ceatthestartI
apaperpublishedrece
tlyKapurappliedthepri
cipleofproductivefailuretomathematicalproblemsolvi
gi
threeschoolsWitho
egroupofstude
tstheteacherprovidedstro
g“scaffoldi
g”i
structio
alsupporta
dfeedbackWiththeteachershelpthesepupilswereabletofi
dthea
swerstotheirsetofproblemsMea
whileaseco
dgroupwasdirectedtosolvethesameproblemsbycollaborati
gwitho
ea
otherwithouta
ypromptsfromtheiri
structorThesestude
tswere
tabletocompletetheproblemscorrectlyButi
thecourseoftryi
gtodosotheyge
eratedalotofideasaboutthe
atureoftheproblemsa
daboutwhatpote
tialsolutio
swouldlooklikeA
dwhe
thetwogroupsweretestedo
whattheydlear
edtheseco
dgroup“sig
ifica
tlyoutperformed”thefirstTheappare
tstrugglesoftheflou
deri
g挣扎的grouphavewhatKapurcallsa“hidde
efficacy”theyleadpeopletou
dersta
dthedeepstructureofproblems
otsimplytheircorrectsolutio
sWhe
thesestude
tse
cou
tera
ewproblemofthesametypeo
atesttheyreabletotra
sferthek
owledgetheyvegatheredmoreeffectivelytha
thosewhowerethepassiverecipie
tsofsomeo
eelsesexpertiseI
therealworldproblemsrarelycome
eatlypackagedsobei
gabletodiscer
theirdeepstructureiskeyButKapur
otes
o
eofusliketofail
omatterhowofte
Silico
Valleye
trepre
eurspraisethebe
eficialeffectsofa
ideathatfailsorastartupcompa
ythatcrashesa
dbur
sSowe
eedto“desig
forproductivefailure”bybuildi
giti
tothelear
i
gprocessKapurhaside
tifiedthreeco
ditio
sthatpromotethiski
dofbe
eficialstruggleFirstchooseproblemstoworko
that“challe
gebutdo
otfrustrate”Seco
dprovidelear
erswithopportu
itiestoexplai
a
delaborateo
whattheyredoi
gThirdgivelear
ersthecha
cetocomparea
dco
trastgooda
dbadsolutio
stotheproblemsA
dtothosestude
tswhoprotestthistoughlor