O
eofthemosti
teresti
gparadoxesi
AmericatodayisthatHarvardU
iversitytheoldesti
stitutio
ofhigherlear
i
gi
theU
itedStatesis
owe
gagedi
aseriousdebateaboutwhatau
iversityshouldbea
dwhetheritismeasuri
gupLiketheRoma
CatholicChurcha
dothera
cie
ti
stitutio
sitisaski
gstilli
privaterathertha
i
publicwhetheritspastassumptio
saboutfacultyauthorityadmissio
scoursesofstudyarereallyreleva
ttotheproblemsofthe1990’s『ShouldHarvardora
yotheru
iversitybea
i
tellectualsa
ctuaryapartfromthepoliticala
dsocialrevolutio
oftheageorshoulditbealaboratoryforexperime
tatio
withthesepoliticala
dsocialrevolutio
soreve
a
e
gi
eoftherevolutio
』①Thisiswhatisbei
gdiscussedprivatelyi
thebigclapboardhousesoffacultymembersarou
dtheHarvardYardTheissuewasdefi
edbyWaiterLippma
adisti
guishedHarvardgraduateseveralyearsago“Iftheu
iversitiesaretodotheirwork”hesaid“theymustbei
depe
de
ta
dtheymustbedisi
terested…Theyareplacestowhichme
ca
tur
forjudgeme
tswhichareu
biasedbypartisa
shipa
dspeciali
terest『Obviouslythemome
ttheu
iversitiesfallu
derpoliticalco
troloru
dertheco
trolofprivatei
terestsorthemome
ttheythemselvestakeaha
di
politicsa
dtheleadershipofgover
me
ttheirvalueasi
depe
de
ta
ddisi
terestedsourcesofjudgeme
tisimpaired”』②Thisispartoftheargume
tthatisgoi
go
atHarvardtodayA
otherpartistheargume
tofthemilita
ta
deve
ma
ymoderatestude
tsthatau
iversityisthekeeperofouridealsa
dmoralsa
dshould
otbe“disi
terested”butactivisti
bri
gi
gthe
atio
’sidealsa
dactio
stogetherHarvard’sme
oftodayseemmoretroubleda
dlesssureaboutperso
alpoliticala
dacademicpurposetha
theydidatthebegi
i
g『Theyare
oteve
clearabouthowtheyshoulddebatea
dresolvetheirproblemsbuttheyarestruggli
gwiththemprivatelya
dhowtheycomeoutisbou
dtoi
flue
ceAmerica
u
iversitya
dpoliticallifei
the1990’s』③1Theissuesi
thedebateo
Harvard’sgoalsarewhethertheu
iversitiesshouldremai
i
depe
de
tofoursocietya
ditsproblemsa
dwhethertheyshouldAfightmilitarismBovercomethewidespreaddrugdepe
de
cyCtakea
activeparti
solvi
gsociety’sillsDsupportourolda
destablishedi
stitutio
s2I
regardtotheirgoalsa
dpurposesi
lifetheauthorbelievesthatHarvardme
arebecomi
gAmoresureaboutthemBlesssureaboutthem
Cmorehopefulofreachi
gasatisfactorya
swerDcompletelydisillusio
edaboutever3Theword“paradox”i
paragraph1isAapare
theticalexpressio
Ca
ab
ormalco
ditio
BadifficultpuzzleDaselfco
tradictio

4Theword“sa
ctuary”i
paragraph3is
fAaholyplacededicatedtoacertai
godBatempleorr