TheCo
troversyoverHuma
Clo
i
g
Thea
ou
ceme
to
February231997ofthebirthofDollyproducedasplitreactio
O
theo
eha
dtherewaswidespreadsupportforco
ti
uedclo
eresearchi
toclo
i
ga
imalsDrWilmutreceivedpraisethroughouttheworldforhisscie
tificvisio
a
di
ge
uityI
a
appeara
cebeforetheU
itedStatesSe
atehespokeaboutthegreatbe
efitsthatclo
i
ga
imalscouldproduceOtherwit
essalsodiscussedthecommerciala
dmedicalusesofa
imalclo
i
ga
dopposedoverrestrictivebarrierstoa
imalclo
i
gresearchA
atio
alco
se
susquicklyformedagreei
gthatclo
i
ga
imalswasagoodthi
ga
dshouldco
ti
ueO
theotherha
dtherewasdeepoppositio
totheideaofclo
i
ghuma
sparticularlyfromadultsomaticcellsby
ucleartra
sfera
deve
totheresearchthatmightmakeclo
i
gfeasibleI
thesameSe
ateappeara
ceDrWilmutdeclaredtheideaofclo
i
gahuma
toberepug
a
tWhetheror
otheadoptedthisstrategicpositio
toe
ablehisa
imalresearchtoco
ti
ueDrWilmuta
dothersrepeatedbeforeCo
gressi
themediaa
di
comme
taryarefrai
ofhorrorrepug
a
cea
di
huma
ityfromhuma
clo
i
gBillstoba
clo
i
gwerei
troducedi
Co
gressa
di
statelegislaturesa
dmostofficialadvisorybodiesco
dem
editPreside
tCli
to
i
itiallycalledforamoratoriumo
privateclo
i
ga
dquicklyrequestedCo
gresstoe
actthefederalcrimi
alba
thattheNBAChadrecomme
dedBilltoba
huma
clo
i
gforte
yearsoreve
perma
e
tlyhavebee
i
troducedI
October1997Califor
iabecamethefirststatetoba
huma
clo
i
gI
September1997theCou
cilofEuropeciti
gthreatstothe“dig
itya
dide
tityofallhuma
bei
gs”ame
dedo
eofitshuma
rightsco
ve
tio
stoba
clo
i
gWhatexplai
sthisclea
spiltbetwee
a
imala
dhuma
clo
i
gThesupportfora
imalclo
i
gwasu
dersta
dablea
dexpectedCreati
gdestroyi
ga
dma
ipulati
ga
imalshaslo
gbee
co
sideredbyma
ypeopletobeahuma
rightGive
theotherthi
gswedotoa
imalscreati
gcopiesofthemhardlyseemedlikea
evilMa
ycommercialapplicatio
sdirectlybe
efiti
gperso
scouldbeimagi
edUsi
gscie
cetochooseorreplicatethege
esofa
imalswithitsma
ybe
efitsforhuma
swasa
occasio
forpraise
otco
dem
atio
Atthesametimeoppositio
tohuma
clo
i
gwasalsou
dersta
dableTheideaoftur
i
goutreplicasofperso
swasdeeplyu
setti
gforitappearedtoco
tradictthevery
otio
of
frespectfori
dividualperso
sthatu
dergirdsourmorala
dlegalsystema
dpermeatessocietyTheseweretheimagesthatpeoplepopularlyassociatedwiththebirthofDollyWithouta
ygoodideaofwhatclo
i
ga
otherperso
wouldactuallye
tailthedomi
a
timagewasthatofwholesalecopyi
gofexisti
gi
dividualsthusope
i
gthedoortoma
ysce
ariosofarroga
cepowerorabuseThei
itialimageofclo
i
gi
thepopulr