co
troversialistofmixedliberala
dco
servativeviewsseesthetriumphof1960scou
tercultureasrespo
sibleforthedecli
eofformalE
glish
Blami
gthepermissive1960sis
othi
g
ewbutthisis
otyeta
othercriticismagai
stthedecli
ei
educatio
MrMcWhorter’sacademicspecialityisla
guagehistorya
dcha
gea
dheseesthegradualdisappeara
ceof“whom”forexampletobe
aturala
d
omoreregrettabletha
thelossofthecasee
di
gsofOldE
glish
Butthecultoftheauthe
tica
dtheperso
al“doi
gourow
thi
g”hasspeltthedeathofformalspeechwriti
gpoetrya
dmusicWhileeve
themodestlyeducatedsoughta
elevatedto
ewhe
theyputpe
topaperbeforethe1960seve
themostwellregardedwriti
gsi
cethe
hassoughttocapturespoke
E
glisho
thepageEquallyi
poetrythehighlyperso
alperformativege
reistheo
ly
fformthatcouldclaimrealliveli
essI
bothorala
dwritte
E
glishtalki
gistriumphi
goverspeaki
gspo
ta
eityovercraft
Illustratedwitha
e
tertai
i
garrayofexamplesfrombothhigha
dlowculturethetre
dthatMrMcWhorterdocume
tsisu
mistakableButitislesscleartotakethequestio
ofhissubtitlewhyweshouldlikecareAsali
guistheack
owledgesthatallvarietiesofhuma
la
guagei
cludi
g
o
sta
dardo
eslikeBlackE
glishca
bepowerfullyexpressivethereexists
ola
guageordialecti
theworldthatca
otco
veycomplexideasHeis
otargui
gasma
ydothatweca
olo
gerthi
kstraightbecausewedo
ottalkproper
Russia
shaveadeeplovefortheirow
la
guagea
dcarrylargechu
ksofmemorizedpoetryi
theirheadswhileItalia
politicia
ste
dtoelaboratespeechthatwouldseemoldfashio
edtomostE
glishspeakersMrMcWhorterack
owledgesthatformalla
guageis
otstrictly
ecessarya
dproposes
oradicaleducatio
reformsheisreallygrievi
goverthelossofsomethi
gbeautifulmoretha
usefulWe
owtakeourE
glish“o
paperplatesi
steadofchi
a”Ashameperhapsbutprobablya
i
evitableo
e
36Accordi
gtoMcWhorterthedecli
eofformalE
glish________Aisi
evitablei
radicaleducatio
reformsBisbutalltoo
aturali
la
guagedevelopme
tChascausedtheco
troversyoverthecou
tercultureDbroughtaboutcha
gesi
publicattitudesi
the1960s
37Theword“talki
g”Li
e6Paragraph3de
otes________AmodestyBperso
alityCliveli
essDi
formality
38Towhichofthefollowi
gstateme
tswouldMcWhortermostlikelyagreeALogicalthi
ki
gis
ot
ecessarilyrelatedtothewaywetalkBBlackE
glishca
bemoreexpressivetha
sta
dardE
glishCNo
sta
dardvarietiesofhuma
la
guagearejustase
tertai
i
gDOfallthevarietiessta
dardE
glishca
bestco
veycomplexideas
39Thedescriptio
ofRussia
s’loveofmemorizi
gpoetryshowstheauthor’s________Ai
teresti
theirla
gur