thestatusquoofpeerreviewedresearchTheydo
otfu
dpeerreviewedresearchTheyperpetuatethemythofthelo
ege
iusThegoalsoftheprizegiversseemasscatteredasthecriticismSomewa
ttoshockotherstodrawpeoplei
toscie
ceortobetterrewardthosewhohavemadetheircareersi
researchAsNaturehaspoi
tedoutbeforethereeresomelegitimateco
cer
sabouthowscie
ceprizeboth
ewa
doldaredistributedTheBreakthroughPrizei
LifeScie
ceslau
chedthisyeartakesa
u
represe
tativeviewofwhatthelifescie
cei
cludeButtheNobelFou
datio
’slimitthreerecipie
tsperprizeeach
7
fofwhommuststillbelivi
ghaslo
gbee
outgrow
bythecollaborative
atureofmoder
researchaswillbedemo
stratedbythei
evitablerowoverwhoisig
oredwhe
itcomestoack
owledgi
gthediscoveryoftheHiggsboso
TheNobelwereofcoursethemselvessetupbyaveryrichi
dividualwhohaddecidedwhathewa
tedtodowithhisow
mo
eyTimerathertha
i
te
tio
hasgive
themlegitimacyAsmuchassomescie
tistsmaycomplai
aboutthe
ewawardstwothi
gsseemclearFirstmostresearcherswouldacceptsuchaprizeiftheywereofferedo
eSeco
ditissurelyagoodthi
gthatthemo
eya
datte
tio
cometoscie
cerathertha
goelsewhereItisfairtocriticizea
dquestio
themecha
ismthatisthecultureofresearchafterallbutitistheprizegivers’mo
eytodowithastheypleaseItiswisetotakesuchgiftswithgratitudea
dgrace31TheFu
dame
talPhysicsPrizeissee
asAasymbolofthee
trepre
eurs’wealthBaha
dsomerewardforresearchersCapossiblereplaceme
toftheNobelPrizesDa
exampleofba
kers’i
vestme
ts32Thecriticsthi
kthatthe
ewawardswillmostbe
efitAtheprofitorie
tedscie
tistsBtheachieveme
tbasedsystemCthefou
dersofthe
ewawardsDpeerreviewledresearch33ThediscoveryoftheHiggsboso
isatypicalcasewhichi
volvesAlegitimateco
cer
soverthe
ewprizesBco
troversiesovertherecipie
ts’statusCthejoi
teffortofmoder
researchersDthedemo
stratio
ofresearchfi
di
g34Accordi
gtoParagraph4whichofthefollowi
gistrueoftheNobelsAHistoryhas
evercastdoubto
them
8
fBtheire
dura
cehasdo
ejusticetothemCTheyarethemostreprese
tativeho
orDTheirlegitimacyhaslo
gbee
i
dispute35Theauthorbelievesthatthe
ewawardsareAu
worthyofpublicatte
tio
Bsubjecttou
desirablecha
gesCharmfultothecultureofresearchDacceptabledespitethecriticismText4—TheHearoftheMatter‖thejustreleasedreportbytheAmerica
AcademyofArtsa
dscie
cesAAASdeservespraiseforaffirmi
gtheimporta
ceofthehuma
itiesa
dsocialscie
cestotheprosperitya
dsecurityofliberaldemocracyi
AmericaRegrettablyhoweverthereport’sfailuretoaddressthetrue
atureor