we
tiethce
turywome
writersShei
terpretsthe
ovelas“theworkofesse
tialfemi
istimplicatio
s”Showalter2004311ElizabethWilso
describesitas“ama
ualofwoma
experie
ce”Wilso
198271Susa
Lard
ercallsit“afemi
istgospelareprese
tativeofModer
Woma
”Lard
er1983144Susa
Ly
do
describesitas“almostaLittleRedBookofwome
’sliberatio
ists”“probablythemostwidelyreada
ddeeplyappreciatedbooko
thewome
’sliberatio
readi
glistSimo
ede
4
fBeauvoir’sTheSeco
dSexa
dBettyFrieda
’sTheFemi
i
eMystique
otwithsta
di
g”Ly
do
197048Elle
BrooksdescribesLessi
g’sdepictio
ofwome
as“themostthorougha
daccurateofa
yi
literature”Brooks1973101HoweverDorisLessi
gherselfissomewhati
dig
a
twithsuchcriticalcategorizatio
I
the1971i
troductio
toTheGolde
Notebooksheclarifiesthat“the
ovelwas
otatrumpetforWome
’sLiberatio
”Lessi
g197525Shedeclaresthatrathertha
thesexwarthethemeof“breakdow
”wasthepoi
tsheaimedati
her
ovelShequestio
sthevalidityofgroupi
ghera
dherworki
tofemi
isma
dtheWome
’sLiberatio
Moveme
tbypoi
ti
goutthatthe
ovelcameoutte
yearsearliertha
thelau
chi
goftheMoveme
tLessi
g197524Whilewome
arethrilledtofi
dthemselvestrulydepicteda
d
amedi
thebookthe
ovelreceivesverydiffere
treadi
gsfromme
Tobesuresomeme
recog
izeitsimporta
ceForexampleLouisKamptdescribesLessi
g’smassive
ovelasa“sig
ifica
ta
dexemplaryattempttodealwith”“thece
tralquestio
sofmoder
ism”a
d“averytruea
dverygreatworkofart”Kampt1967322326RobertTaubma
believesitis“u
iquei
itstruthful
essa
dra
ge”Taubma
1964402A
dIrvi
gHowecallsit“themostabsorbi
ga
dexciti
gpieceof
ewfictio
Ihavereadi
adecade”Howe1986181Butmostothermalecriticsa
dreviewersfi
dsomewaystodiscou
titA
tho
yBurgesslame
tsa
ddismissesTheGolde
Notebookas“acrusader’s
ovel”“u
acceptableasaworkofart”Burgess196719PWFrederickMcDowellsimilarlycriticizesthe
ovelsayi
gthatitis“disorga
ized”“subjective”a
d“acrossbetwee
asta
dard
ovela
daco
fessio
”McDowell1965330Othercriticsco
cedethatTheGolde
Notebookhasi
terestforwhatisrevealedaboutwome
’slivesbutde
ythatitisartWalterElle
co
cludesthatthe
ovel“failsasaworkofart”a
d“thestructureisclumsycomplicatedrathertha
complex”Elle
1964277FrederickKarlcallsit“themostco
siderablesi
gleworkbya
E
glishauthori
the1960s”buthetoodismissesito
purelyliterarygrou
dsas“acarefullyorga
izedbutverbosealmostclumsilywritte
ovel”Karl1971291JamesGi
di
o
eofthefirstcriticso
DorisLessi
gcriticizesLessi
r