whethera
yparticularpapershadimpelledthecha
geMcNuttsaid—Thecreatio
ofthestatisticsboard‘wasmotivatedbyco
cer
sbroadlywiththeapplicatio
ofstatisticsa
ddataa
alysisi
scie
tificresearcha
dispartofScie
ce‘soveralldrivetoi
creasereproducibilityi
theresearchwepublish‖Giova
iParmigia
iabiostatisticia
attheHarvardSchoolofPublicHealthamemberoftheSBoREgroupHesaysheexpectstheboardto—playprimarilya
advisoryrole‖Heagreedtojoi
becausehe—fou
dtheforesightbehi
dtheestablishme
toftheSBoREtobe
ovelu
iquea
dlikelytohavealasti
gimpactThisimpactwill
oto
lybethroughthepublicatio
si
Scie
ceitselfbuthopefullythroughalargergroupofpublishi
gplacesthatmaywa
ttomodeltheirapproachafterScie
ce‖3
fJoh
Ioa
idisaphysicia
whostudiesresearchmethodologysaysthatthepolicyis—amostwelcomestepforward‖a
d—lo
goverdue‖—Mostjour
alsareweaki
statisticalreviewa
dthisdamagesthequalityofwhattheypublishIthi
kthatforthemajorityofscie
tificpapers
owadaysstatisticalreviewismoreesse
tialtha
expertreview‖hesaysButhe
otedthatbiomedicaljour
alssuchasA
alsofI
ter
alMedici
etheJour
aloftheAmerica
MedicalAssociatio
a
dTheLa
cetpaystro
gatte
tio
tostatisticalreviewProfessio
alscie
tistsareexpectedtok
owhowtoa
alyzedatabutstatisticalerrorsarealarmi
glycommo
i
publishedresearchaccordi
gtoDavidVauxacellbiologistResearchersshouldimprovetheirsta
dardshewrotei
2012butjour
alsshouldalsotakeatougherli
e—e
gagi
greviewerswhoarestatisticallyliteratea
deditorswhoca
verifytheprocess‖VauxsaysthatScie
ce‘sideatopasssomepaperstostatisticia
s—hassomemeritbutaweak
essisthatitrelieso
theboardofreviewi
geditorstoide
tifythepapersthat
eedscruti
y‘i
thefirstplace‖31Itca
belear
edfromParagraph1thatAScie
cei
te
dstosimplifytheirpeerreviewprocessBjour
alsarestre
gthe
i
gtheirstatisticalchecksCfewjour
alsareblamedformistakesi
dataa
alysisDlackofdataa
alysisiscommo
i
researchprojects32Thephrase—flaggedup‖Para2istheclosesti
mea
i
gtoAfou
dBmarkedCrevisedDstored33Giova
iParmigia
ibelievesthattheestablishme
toftheSBoREmayAposeathreattoallitspeersText4TwoyearsagoRupertMurdoch‘sdaughterElisabethspokeofthe—u
settli
gdearthofi
tegrityacrosssoma
yofouri
stitutio
s‖I
tegrityhadcollapsedshearguedbecauseofacollectiveaccepta
cethattheo
ly—sorti
gmecha
ism‖i
societyshouldbeprofita
dthemarketBut—it‘sushuma
bei
gswethepeoplewhocreatethesocietywewa
t
otprofit‖Drivi
gherpoi
thomesheco
ti
ued—It‘si
creasi
glyappare
tthattheabse
ceofr